Ernst Mayr was one of the 20th century's leading evolutionary
biologists. He was at the same time a naturalist, an explorer,
an ornithologist and science historian. His work contributed to
the conceptual revolution that led to the modern evolutionary
synthesis of Mendelian genetics and Darwinian evolution, and to
the development of the biological species concept.
Neither
Darwin nor anyone else in his time knew the answer to the 'species
problem': how could different species evolve from one common ancestor.
Ernst Mayr approached the problem with a new definition for the
concept 'species'. In his book 'Systematics and the Origin of
Species' (1942) he wrote that a species is not a group of morphologically
similar individuals, but a group that can breed only among themselves,
excluding all others. When groups of identical individuals get
isolated, the sub-populations will start to differ by genetic
drift and natural selection over a period of time, and thereby
evolve into new species.
His
theory of peripatric speciation (a more precise term for the subset
of allopatric speciation he supported) based on his work on birds
is considered as one typical mode of speciation, and is the basis
of the theory of punctuated equilibrium. Apart from biological
subjects, his prolific writings include works on the philosophy
and history of science in general, and of biology in particular.
Biography
Mayr was born in Kempten and completed his high school education
in Dresden. He planned to become a physician and completed his
preclinical studies in 1925. However he was attracted to ornithology,
and was introduced to Erwin Stresemann due to his claimed sighting
of Red-crested Pochards in Germany, a species that had not been
seen in Europe for 77 years. After a tough interrogation, Stresemann
accepted and published the sighting as authentic. Stresemann offered
him a position with the Berlin Museum and the prospect of bird-collecting
trips to the tropics on the condition that he completed his PhD
studies in 16 months. Mayr completed his PhD in ornithology at
the University of Berlin in June 1926 at the age of 21 and accepted
the position offered to him at the Museum.
At
the International Zoological Congress at Budapest in 1927, Mayr
was introduced by Stresemann to banker and naturalist Walter Rothschild,
who asked him to undertake an expedition to New Guinea on behalf
of himself and the American Museum of Natural History in New York.
In New Guinea Mayr collected several thousands bird skins (he
named 26 new bird species during his lifetime) and, in the process
also named 38 new orchid species. During his stay in New Guinea,
he was invited to accompany the Whitney South Seas Expedition
to the Solomon Islands.
He
returned to Germany in 1930 and in 1931 he accepted a curatorial
position at the American Museum of Natural History, where he played
the important role of brokering and acquiring the Walter Rothschild
collection of bird skins, which was being sold in order to pay
off a blackmailer. During his time at the museum he produced numerous
publications on bird taxonomy, and in 1942 his first book, Systematics
and the Origin of Species, which completed the evolutionary synthesis
started by Darwin.
After
Mayr was appointed at the American Museum of Natural History,
he influenced American ornithological research by cultivating
mentoring relationships with young birdwatchers. Mayr organized
a monthly seminar under the auspices of the Linnaean Society of
New York. This society, under the influence of J. A. Allen, Frank
Chapman and Jonathan Dwight concentrated on taxonomy and later
became a clearing house for bird banding and sight records.
There
were a group of eight young birdwatchers from the Bronx and later
became the Bronx County Bird Club and they were led by Ludlow
Griscom. Mayr was surprised at the differences between American
and German Birding Societies. He noted that the German society
was "far more scientific, far more interested in life histories
and breeding bird species, as well as in reports on recent literature."
Mayr
also encouraged his Linnaean Society seminar participants to take
up a specific research project of their own. "Everyone should
have a problem" was the way one Bronx County Bird Club member
recalled Mayr's refrain. One of Mayr's seminar participants was
Joseph Hickey and under Mayr's influence went on to write A Guide
to Birdwatching (1943). Hickey remembered later –"Mayr
was our age and invited on all our field trips. The heckling of
this German foreigner was tremendous, but he gave tit for tat,
and any modern picture of Dr E. Mayr as a very formal person does
not square with my memory of the 1930's.
He
held his own." Mayr's said of his own involvement with the
local birdwatchers: "In those early years in New York when
I was a stranger in a big city, it was the companionship and later
friendship which I was offered in the Linnean Society that was
the most important thing in my life."
Another
person that Mayr greatly influenced was Margaret Morse Nice. Mayr
encouraged her to correspond with the European ornithologists
of the time, and helped her in her landmark study on Song Sparrows.
Nice wrote to Joseph Grinnell in 1932 trying to get foreign literature
reviewed in the Condor: "Too many American ornithologists
have despised the study of the living bird; the magazine[s] and
books that deal with the subject abound in careless statements,
anthropomorphic interpretations, repetition of ancient errors,
and sweeping conclusions from a pitiful array of facts. ... in
Europe the study of the living bird is taken seriously. We could
learn a great deal from their writing." Mayr ensured that
Nice could publish her two volume Studies in the Life History
of the Song Sparrow, finding her a publisher, and her book was
reviewed by Aldo Leopold, Grinnell, Jean Delacour. Nice dedicated
her book to "My Friend Ernst Mayr."
Mayr
joined the faculty of Harvard University in 1953, where he also
served as director of the Museum of Comparative Zoology from 1961
to 1970. He retired in 1975 as emeritus professor of zoology,
showered with honors. Following his retirement, he went on to
publish more than 200 articles, in a variety of journals—more
than some reputable scientists publish in their entire careers;
14 of his 25 books were published after he was 65. Even as a centenarian,
he continued to write books. On his 100th birthday, he was interviewed
by Scientific American magazine.
He
received awards including the National Medal of Science, the Balzan
Prize and the International Prize for Biology. He was never awarded
a Nobel Prize, but he noted that there is no Prize for evolutionary
biology, and that Darwin would not have received one, either.
Mayr
was co-author of six global reviews of bird species new to science
(listed below).
Mayr's
ideas
As a traditionally trained biologist with little mathematical
experience, Mayr was often highly critical of early mathematical
approaches to evolution such as those of J. B. S. Haldane, famously
calling in 1959 such approaches "bean bag genetics".
He maintained that factors such as reproductive isolation had
to be taken into account. In a similar fashion, Mayr was also
quite critical of molecular evolutionary studies such as those
of Carl Woese.
In
many of his writings, Mayr rejected reductionism in evolutionary
biology, arguing that evolutionary pressures act on the whole
organism, not on single genes, and that genes can have different
effects depending on the other genes present. He advocated a study
of the whole genome rather than of isolated genes only. Current
molecular studies in evolution and speciation indicate that although
allopatric speciation seems to be the norm in groups (possibly
those with greater mobility) such as the birds, there are numerous
cases of sympatric speciation in many invertebrates (especially
in the insects).
Mayr
was an outspoken defender of the scientific method, and one known
to sharply critique science on the edge. As a notable recent example,
he criticized the search for aliens as conducted by fellow Harvard
professor Paul Horowitz as being a waste of university and student
resources, for its inability to address and answer a scientific
question.
|